Santa's Nice List

Pearhead Snowman Dog Toy is a soft, plush toy with a squeaker and rope. This fun and festive pet toy will bring cheer and tail wags to your four-le...

Pearhead Reindeer Dog Toy is a soft, plush toy with a squeaker and rope. This fun and festive pet toy will bring cheer and tail wags to your four-l...

Outward Hound Hedgehogz with Santa Hat Dog Toy is a honking, rattling good time! This squeaky toy is perfect for crate cuddles and stocking stuffer...

This holiday season, satisfy your pup's sweet tooth with Zippy Paws' Gingerbread Donutz. Featuring festive embroidered "sprinkles" and two squeaker...

Add some holly jolly fun to your pup's playtime with the Zippy Paws Holiday Jigglerz! These super cute, super long plush toys squeak when shaken, p...

Treat your cat to a purr-fectly cheery time with this famous Holiday duo: Santa Claus and his bright-nosed Reindeer sidekick! Packed with premium c...

Treat your cat to a purr-fectly cheery time with this famous Holiday duo: a Gingerbread cookie and a swirly Peppermint candy sidekick! Packed with ...

Fabdog's Twisty Candy Cane Dog Toy is packed with playful surprises: three squeakers hidden within the soft sherpa shell, along with an abundance o...

Description Sizes Give your cat all the fun without the worry with this whimsical Nip Nog bottle! Made with a soft shell and filled to the brim...

This FuzzYard Holiday Jolly Old St Pickl-ous cat toy is the perfect gift to give your feline friend this season, while also getting you laughing in...

This FuzzYard holiday Merry Fishmas toy is the perfect gift to give your feline friend this season! It features an adorable, bright fish with stuff...

Description Sizes This sweet, squeaky Tree Rex is the perfect holiday companion for your pup! Made from extra-durable mesh and a soft outer she...

Description Sizes This sweet, squeaky bear is the perfect holiday companion for your pup! Made from extra-durable mesh and a soft outer shell, ...

Description Sizes This sweet, squeaky Yeti is the perfect holiday companion for your pup! Made from extra-durable mesh and a soft outer shell, ...

Description Sizes This grumpy, feathery Christmas kitty is the perfect holiday companion for your cat! Made with a soft shell and filled to the...

Description Sizes Give your cat a fun, active play-time with the Santa Teaser! Your kitty will leap, run and stalk as the leather tassels gli...

Description Sizes Much like a present, the Merry Chris-Mouse tears away in layers, providing your pup with several levels of entertainment! The...

The Holiday St. Nick Knottie Dog Toy is here to make your pup’s holiday extra festive and fun! St. Nick’s arms and legs are adorned with HuggleHoun...

The Noel Narwhal Dog Toy is here to make your pup’s holiday extra festive and fun! Noel has a small squeaker in his tail and a larger squeaker hidd...

The Holiday Tundra Polar Bear Knottie Dog Toy is here to make your pup’s holiday extra festive and fun! The Polar Bear’s arms and legs are adorned ...

Description Sizes Unleash your pup’s “wild side” this holiday season with the Tall Tails Gnome 2-in-1 Dog Toy! This shy yet friendly Gnome (an...

Description Sizes Unleash your pup’s “wild side” this holiday season with the Tall Tails Moose 2-in-1 Dog Toy! This majestic and friendly Moos...

One of the most beloved breakfast treats is making a special appearance this holiday season—meet the ultra-adorable FuzzYard Bacon plush! This fest...

While children may dream of dancing sugarplums, our furry friends are eagerly awaiting a very special holiday guest: Jolly Old St. Pickl-ous! With ...